We changed up how we sold Christmas Cookies this year (trying a market only approach - but to be honest and transparent - it did not go as planned. (NEXT YEAR WILL BE BACK TO OUR USUAL POSTING FOR PRE-ORDERS for ALL of the Holidays again)
Customer Reviews (Scroll right to see more)
I can see why you're so busy. The cookies look even better in person than in the pics! Absolutely gorgeous!!😍 I also love your presentation and packaging. Very elegant 🥰
I'm very happy with the finished product, Lindsay. You did an amazing job!! Can't wait to show them off at the shower on Saturday
Daniela Lanese
Lindsay was an absolute pleasure to work with when creating the cookies that I wanted for my daughters baptism. She took the time to show me different styles and examples of things she thought I would like. She responded quickly to all emails and answered all my questions. The cookies were so delicious and the packaging was perfect for the guests to take home. I cannot wait to use her again for another event. Absolutely 100% recommend!!
Toni Ianniello
Cookies were tasty and beautiful ! Pleasant and timely to deal with. I froze my cookies and followed the instructions on the cards you sent they turned out perfect.
Alyson Gasperetti
Everything was wonderful! The prices were great, the cookies were incredible, and the packaging was above and beyond what I had expected.
Lindsey Riedke
The detail on my husband's retirement cookies is meticulous and they are absolutely delicious! Each a work of art that taste like heaven.
Heather Kendell
Lindsay did an amazing job on my sand dollar sugar cookies for my sisters bridal shower!! They’re elegant and look like a real life sand dollar and they taste amazing, the cookie itself is very soft and melts in your mouth. The vanilla bean icing is amazing !!
Kennedy Knezevich
Sugar Shack Bake Shoppe which made some cookies for my dads retirement which included all of his favourite things! To say they were a huge hit is an understatement. The work that went into these cookies is insane and they taste like they just came out of the oven. If I could, I'd give it more than 5 starts and they certainly are worth the 4.5 hour round trip to go down and pick them up! I will be back for sure again soon.
Megan Forsythe
My Brother and Sister-in-law had their 60th birthdays in the same week and we wanted to have something special. With allergies in the family we were able to select our ingredients to ensure our guests were as safe as possible and we were able to outline our themes and interests of the birthday boy and girl!!! Sugar Shack Bake Shoppe provided an awesome experience, not only for the guests of honor, but everyone that attended.... Thanks Sugar Shack.... We'll be back!
Robert Wyatt
Really wanted to THANK YOU and tell you how AMAZING the cookies you made for Jamie and Dagmar's 60th bdays were. You do amazing work! The detail is phenominal AND the taste WOW!! Very good to say the least! They were a HUGE hit at our small gathering. No one wanted to eat them as they were too nice to ruin lol.
Maureen McMillan Wyatt
More Customer Reviews.......
Blown away by the sugar cookies I got from Sugar Shack Bake Shoppe tonight. Called last week asking if she could do a dozen gluten friendly cookies for me. I didn't care what they looked like, they were just for me to put in the freezer for my sweet tooth. WOW Lindsay you did an AMAZING job hun, and they taste as good as they look! Thank you and promise to spread the word on how fantastic these cookies are!
